Metaplanet’s executive stock pool sparks shareholder backlash as CEO addresses MMXX ties
Shareholders of Japanese Bitcoin treasury firm Metaplanet are protesting an expanded executive option pool that critics say has substantially diluted existing holders. The dispute centers on a 10th Series option plan designed as 20% of fully diluted shares that grew automatically as new shares were issued for Bitcoin accumulation, prompting calls to freeze exercise rights tied to roughly 273 million shares.
Why It Matters
The conflict highlights tensions between management incentives and shareholder value in companies using equity to fund cryptocurrency purchases, and raises governance questions about automatic expansion of executive option pools without fresh shareholder approval.
Key Facts
- Company: Metaplanet (Japanese Bitcoin treasury company)
- Contested plan: 10th Series executive option pool set at 20% of fully diluted shares
- Reported pool expansion: Grew from 46 million shares to 319.5 million shares
- Additional shares disputed: Approximately 273 million shares
- Company action: Says it froze the pool at 319.5 million shares on Aug. 18 (company statement)
Shareholders of Metaplanet have voiced strong objections to the company’s 10th Series executive option pool after it expanded alongside new share issuances used to build the firm’s Bitcoin holdings. The plan was structured to equal 20% of fully diluted shares and, according to critics, automatically increased as the company issued stock, causing the pool to swell from about 46 million shares to 319.5 million.
Investor calls for relief have included demands that Metaplanet cancel roughly 273 million of the newly created option shares and provide clearer disclosures about future governance decisions. The company said it froze the pool at 319.5 million shares on Aug. 18, but opponents say the expansion already magnified dilution for existing shareholders.
Prominent figures have entered the debate. Bitcoin Magazine CEO David Bailey defended the executive stock model on social media, arguing that allocating 20% of the cap table over five years is reasonable and noting his outlet’s early investment in Metaplanet. A pseudonymous shareholder, Bitcoin Pharaoh, alleged Bailey personally benefited via 300,000 options with a 105 JPY strike price when the stock traded around 510 JPY, and argued management’s cut reduced the shareholders’ effective bitcoin allocation.
Metaplanet CEO Simon Gerovich said the company will review its governance and compensation policies and sought to distance himself from ties to shareholder MMXX Ventures, stating he is a significant but non-majority shareholder in MMXX’s parent and holds no executive role. The CEO also disclosed he exercised 92,000 shares from the 10th Series pool on Aug. 31. Independent observers, including VanEck’s Matthew Sigel, urged Metaplanet to freeze further exercise rights, consider voluntary surrender of excess rights and replace the Series 10 plan with a shareholder-approved five-year incentive program tied mainly to BTC per fully diluted share.
Metaplanet acknowledged in its Aug. 18 notice that expanding the pool increases dilution for existing shareholders. The company’s shares nevertheless closed higher in Tokyo trading on Wednesday, narrowing a five-day decline to about 16.3% per Yahoo Finance. Cointelegraph has sought comment from Metaplanet on whether it will freeze the remaining shares in the executive pool.
Keep Reading
